Direct Vs Regular Mutual Funds: What Shall You Opt?

Introduction:

When it comes to investing in mutual funds, choosing between direct and regular plans can feel like deciding between cooking your own meal or dining at a restaurant. Both options lead to the same outcome — your investment grows — but the costs, convenience, and involvement vary significantly.

Direct mutual funds are like cooking at home: you save on service charges but must know your ingredients well. Regular mutual funds resemble dining out — you pay for expert preparation and guidance. Understanding which approach suits your financial appetite can make a big difference in your returns.

What Are Direct and Regular Mutual Funds?

Direct Mutual Funds

Direct mutual funds are purchased directly from the asset management company (AMC) without involving intermediaries such as brokers or agents. As a result, these funds have a lower expense ratio, which directly improves your net returns. Since there are no commissions or distribution costs involved, you save on fees that would otherwise reduce your earnings.

For instance, if you invest ₹1 lakh in a direct mutual fund with a 12% annual return and an expense ratio of 1%, your returns would grow more substantially compared to a regular fund with higher expenses.

Regular Mutual Funds

Regular mutual funds are purchased through intermediaries like brokers, financial advisors, or agents. These intermediaries charge commission fees, which are built into the fund’s expense ratio, making it higher than that of a direct plan. While this increases costs, it comes with added benefits like personalized advice and guidance, which can be especially helpful for first-time investors or those seeking professional insights.

For example, if you invest ₹1 lakh in a regular mutual fund with the same 12% annual return but an expense ratio of 2%, your overall returns would be lower than those of a direct plan.

Key Differences Between Direct and Regular Mutual Funds

Aspect	Direct Mutual Funds	Regular Mutual Funds
Expense Ratio	Lower as no commissions are paid to intermediaries. Typical expense ratio is 0.5% – 1%.	Higher as it includes broker/advisor commissions. Typical expense ratio is 1.5% – 2.5%.
Returns	Higher returns due to lower expenses. For example, a direct fund may offer 1% – 1.5% higher returns annually.	Lower returns as commissions reduce overall gains. The difference can compound significantly over time.
Investment Cycle	Purchased directly via AMC websites, apps, or direct investment platforms.	Purchased through intermediaries such as brokers, agents, or financial advisors.
Advisory Support	No advisory support; investors must research and manage their investments independently. Suitable for experienced investors.	Provides professional guidance in selecting and managing funds. Ideal for beginners or those seeking tailored advice.
NAV (Net Asset Value)	Generally higher because lower expense ratios mean less deduction from fund assets.	Slightly lower NAV as commissions reduce the total value of the investment.
Transparency	Greater transparency as you can track fund performance directly without third-party influence.	Limited transparency as fund decisions may be influenced by commission-driven advisors.
Convenience	Requires more effort to research, select, and track investments independently. Best for confident investors.	Easier for those who prefer professional guidance or lack time for research.

Why Choose Direct Mutual Funds?

Direct mutual funds are an excellent choice for investors seeking higher returns and greater control over their investments. Unlike regular mutual funds, direct funds have lower expense ratios, meaning more of your money stays invested and grows over time.

In regular mutual funds, a portion of the expense ratio is allocated towards distributor commissions. These commissions vary between schemes and brokers, and in some cases, brokers may recommend funds with higher commissions to maximize their earnings. Additionally, some distributors frequently switch investors’ funds every 2–3 years to earn repeated commissions. These practices can significantly reduce your net returns.

Direct mutual funds, on the other hand, eliminate the need for middlemen. Since there are no commissions, the overall expenses are lower, enhancing your returns in the long run. This cost advantage makes direct funds an appealing choice for investors who prefer a hands-on approach.

Investors willing to take the initiative in researching funds and managing their portfolios can benefit greatly from direct funds. While regular funds offer the convenience of distributor support, direct funds provide complete transparency and unbiased information. If you’re unsure about choosing the right fund, consider consulting a SEBI-registered advisor who can guide you towards suitable direct funds for a fixed fee instead of commission-based recommendations.

Example: Imagine you started a monthly SIP of ₹10,000 in a large-cap mutual fund 10 years ago, earning an average annual return of 10%. If you invested in a regular fund, you may have paid over ₹1,00,000 in commission fees during this period. By opting for a direct fund instead, this amount would have remained invested, potentially adding significantly to your returns.

In short, the combination of lower costs, higher potential returns, and increased investment control makes direct mutual funds an attractive option for those willing to manage their portfolios actively.

Why Choose Regular Mutual Funds?

Regular funds are ideal for individuals who may lack extensive knowledge of mutual fund investments. For such investors, relying on a broker can simplify the process by offering guidance and insights. Brokers provide valuable resources like detailed fund analysis and research reports, helping investors make more informed decisions without diving deep into complex financial data.

This approach is particularly beneficial for those who prefer professional support in managing their investments. By leveraging a broker’s expertise, investors gain access to tailored advice, market updates, and strategic recommendations, ensuring they navigate mutual fund investments with greater confidence.

For instance, imagine Ramesh, a working professional with limited knowledge of mutual funds. He wants to invest but feels overwhelmed by the variety of options available. By opting for a regular fund through a financial advisor, Ramesh receives personalized guidance. His advisor suggests a balanced mutual fund suited to his risk appetite and financial goals. Additionally, the advisor provides regular updates, performance reviews, and insights on when to rebalance his portfolio. This professional support helps Ramesh stay informed and confident in his investment decisions, even without in-depth market expertise.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Direct Mutual Funds if:

• You are financially literate and confident in making investment decisions.
• You prefer saving on costs to maximize returns.
• You are comfortable using online platforms for direct investments.

Choose Regular Mutual Funds if:

• You need expert guidance in selecting suitable funds.
• You value personalized advice tailored to your financial goals.
• You are a first-time investor seeking professional insights.

In conclusion, the choice between direct mutual funds and regular mutual funds depends on your investment knowledge and financial goals. While direct plans generally offer better returns, regular plans provide valuable advisory support. Assess your comfort level with financial planning to make the best choice for long-term growth.

Disclaimer Note: The securities quoted, if any, are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. This article is for education purposes only and shall not be considered as a recommendation or investment advice by Equentis – Research & Ranking. We will not be liable for any losses that may occur. Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing. Registration granted by SEBI, membership of BASL & the certification from NISM in no way guarantee the performance of the intermediary or provide any assurance of returns to investors.

FAQ